Two of the most common journal rankings are the Journal Impact Factor (JIF) and SCImago Journal Rank (SJR). They both measure journal impact but in different ways. Knowing how they work can help you choose the right journal to publish in.
If you’re deciding where to publish your research or assessing the significance of journals in your field, understanding these metrics can guide your choices. While both JIF and SJR aim to measure journal impact, they approach it differently. Depending on your needs, you might prefer one over the other or consider both for a well-rounded view.
What Is SJR?
Developed by SCImago using Scopus’s database, SJR ranking evaluates the scientific impact of journals on their citations. Unlike a simple citation count, SJR assigns a higher value to citations from prestigious journals, meaning that not all citations carry the same weight.
Key Features of SJR Ranking:
- Citation Quality Is Important: A journal’s SJR ranking is influenced more by citations from reputable publications.
- Three-Year Citation Window: Citations are taken into account by SJR ranking for a duration of three years.
- Field-Normalised: SJR ranking takes into consideration variations among disciplines, which facilitates the comparison of publications from various fields of study.
- Open Access Inclusion: By incorporating open-access journals, SJR ranking provides a more comprehensive understanding of journal impact.
What Is JIF?
The Journal Impact Factor (JIF) provides one of the most well-known indicators of a journal, run by Clarivate and based on Web of Science database. Unlike SJR ranking, JIF is calculated by a straightforward ratio: the number of citations a journal receives in a given year divided by the number of citable articles published in the previous two years.
Key Features of JIF:
- Two-Year Citation Window – Focuses on recent citations.
- Straightforward Calculation – It is simple to understand because it uses a simple average.
- Exclusive to Web of Science – Only Web of Science-indexed journals are included.
- Heavily Used in Academic Promotion – JIF is often a deciding factor in funding applications and tenure evaluations.
Which Ranking Should You Use?
It depends on what you’re looking for.
- If you need a broader view of journal impact that considers citation prestige, SJR ranking may be more useful.
- If you’re in a field where the Journal Impact Factor is commonly used for assessments (e.g., life sciences, medicine), JIF might be the better choice.
- If you’re working with open-access journals, SJR provides a more inclusive perspective.
In Conclusion
While each ranking system has advantages, none of them is a perfect measurement of journal ranking quality. To have a better view of a journal’s influence, think about examining a variety of classifications rather than depending solely on SJR ranking or JIF ranking. Knowing these distinctions will help you make well-informed choices, whether choosing a journal for publication or assessing a research paper.
Sources: